Kelley Blue Book


HomeSubaruSubaru Legacy
2005 Subaru Legacy

Used 2005 Subaru Legacy

Expert (N/A)
4.5
rating
Consumer
Write a Review
Save this car
2005 Subaru Legacy Exterior: 0
2005 Subaru Legacy Lifestyle: 1
Lifestyle (9)
2005 Subaru Legacy Lifestyle: 2
2005 Subaru Legacy All Media: 1

View All Media

2025
2005
Fuel Economy
19 - 23 combined mpg
Horsepower
168 - 250 hp
Engine
2 engines available
Engine Options
  • 4-Cyl, 2.5 Liter
  • 4-Cyl, Turbo, 2.5 Liter
Cargo Volume
11.4 - 66.2 cu ft
Next Steps: Shopping for this car?
See Cars for Sale

2005 Subaru Legacy Overview

2005 Subaru Legacy Pricing

2005 Subaru Legacy pricing starts at $3,770 for the Legacy 2.5i Sedan 4D, which had a starting MSRP of $22,870 when new. The range-topping 2005 Legacy 2.5 GT Limited Wagon 4D starts at $3,889 today, originally priced from $31,570.

Original MSRP
KBB Fair Purchase Price (national avg.)
2.5i Sedan 4D
$22,870
$3,770
$23,870
$3,422
$26,120
$3,706
$27,320
$3,568
$27,870
$3,447
$28,870
$3,855
$30,370
$3,793
$31,570
$3,889

The Kelley Blue Book Fair Purchase Price for any individual used vehicle can vary greatly according to mileage, condition, location, and other factors. The prices here reflect what buyers are currently paying for used 2005 Subaru Legacy models in typical condition when purchasing from a dealership. These prices are updated weekly.

Legacy Consumer Sentiment

Owners give this generation Subaru Legacy (2005-2009) a 4.5 out of 5 rating, which is higher than most, and 90% recommend it. These figures are based on 314 consumer reviews, like these:

What Owners are Saying About the 2005 Subaru Legacy

"My baby for almost 10 years!!"

"this was my very first car. Bought it used and it had a little over 55,000 miles on it and almost 10 years later, it now has a little over 240,000 miles. Even though this car sits low to ground, it was AMAZING in the winter time (only got "stuck" 3 times in all the years I've owned it), never had to put snow tires on it, but I can only imagine how well the performance would've been if I had. The power steering pump needed to be replaced at about 180K, and the blower motor went out around 125K, but other than those two things, never had any major mechanical issues. The sound system was absolutely AMAZING and it was STOCK - never upgraded it, didn't see the need. But now, my head gasket is failing and I'm searching for a new vehicle - preferably an SUV, I just want more ground clearance than what a car can offer me. I'm gonna miss this car, but sheesh! I've owned it since my last year of high school and almost til the end of my twenties, sooo. It's been good to me!!"

"Fun and nice"

"I bought this 2000 Legacy sedan in 2005 with 34k miles, now in early 2008 it has 82K. I will only drive an AWD, as I live in the snowy hiils of central NY. It is a beast in any weather. I previously owned a Subaru Forester, and the Legacy is so much nicer to drive. It handles like a dream. You don't have to slow down nearly as much to make turns. The seats and ride are comfy. It has been reliable, inexpensive to maintain, and starts up like a gun every time no matter how cold."

"Fun car but..."

"I bought the car brand new in 03/05. Fun car to drive and to drive hard when it is running good. Tires appear to make a huge difference in handling characteristics, too big of a difference in my opinion. Had to replace a bearing in transmission at 62,000 (warranty ran out at 60,000). Car has never liked city speeds or cold and/or damp weather - car chugs (feels like gas is on and off...), very irritating and two dealers could not find a problem. The car has been having erratic idling/running issues since turning 100,000 and throws codes non-stop during these spells. Again, dealer can find nothing wrong but did suggest the cam shaft pulley/filter needed to be changed. Seriously. Bottom line, I would rather of kept the 10 year old car I had and the $32,000 I paid for this, my first new car."

Overall 2005 Subaru Legacy Quality

User sentiment suggests the overall quality of the 2005 Subaru Legacy is above average for its class. Owners rated the 2005 Subaru Legacy quality a 4.6 out of 5.

2005 Subaru Legacy Reliability

The 2005 Subaru Legacy receives an average consumer rating of 4.5 overall and a 4.6 for reliability, which means owners consider its reliability to be above average.

Favorite 2005 Legacy Features

According to drivers of the 2005 Legacy, here are some of its best features:

  • Fantastic ride, good gas mileage
  • Fun, fast, comfortable with decent MPG
  • Nice looking
  • Dependable-Gas Mileage-Fun to Drive-Longevity : )
  • Sporty and fun to drive

2005 Subaru Legacy MPG by Trim

2005 Legacy 2.5i Wagon 4D - city 20 MPG - hwy 27 MPG

2005 Legacy 2.5 GT Sedan 4D - city 17 MPG - hwy 23 MPG

2005 Legacy 2.5i Limited Wagon 4D - city 20 MPG - hwy 27 MPG

2005 Legacy 2.5i Limited Sedan 4D - city 20 MPG - hwy 27 MPG

2005 Legacy 2.5i Sedan 4D - city 20 MPG - hwy 27 MPG

2005 Legacy 2.5 GT Limited Sedan 4D - city 17 MPG - hwy 23 MPG

2005 Legacy 2.5 GT Wagon 4D - city 17 MPG - hwy 23 MPG

2005 Legacy 2.5 GT Limited Wagon 4D - city 17 MPG - hwy 23 MPG

2005 Legacy Safety

2005 Subaru Legacy Safety Features

  • Child Door Locks
  • Child Seat Anchors
  • Driver Airbag
  • Passenger Airbag
  • Rear Side Airbag
  • Front Side Airbag
More About How We Rate Vehicles
Advertisement

New Subaru Legacy Deals and Incentives

APR

3.9% APR | 36 months

Get 3.9% APR Financing for 36 Months on a new 2025 Legacy.

See more details

End Date: 04/30/2025
LEASE

$279 /mo | 36 months | Due at Signing

Lease a new 2025 Legacy Base for $279/month lease for 36 months with $3,279 due at signing.

See more details

End Date: 04/30/2025
CONDITIONAL

$1000 Total Cash

Get $1,000 Subaru Mobility Assist on a new 2025 Legacy (all models).

See more details

End Date: 07/01/2025
See All Current Legacy Deals

2005 Subaru Legacy
KBB.com Consumer Reviews

4.5
Consumer Rating
Based on 314 Consumer Reviews
Write a Review
88%Recommend this vehicle
5
66%
5
66%
4
24%
4
24%
3
4%
3
4%
2
5%
2
5%
1
1%
1
1%
Value
4.6
Performance
4.6
Quality
4.6
Comfort
4.5
Reliability
4.6
Styling
4.6

Trending Topics in KBB.com Consumer Reviews

Advertisement

2005 Subaru Legacy Styles

Style
Price
Combined Fuel Economy
Horsepower
Engine
Cargo Capacity
Torque
Curb Weight
2.5 GT Sedan 4D
$3,447
19 MPG
250 @ 6000 RPM
4-Cyl, Turbo, 2.5 Liter
11.4 cu ft
250 lb-ft
3300 lbs
2.5 GT Limited Sedan 4D
$3,793
19 MPG
250 @ 6000 RPM
4-Cyl, Turbo, 2.5 Liter
11.4 cu ft
250 lb-ft
3365 lbs
2.5i Limited Sedan 4D
$3,706
23 MPG
168 @ 5600 RPM
4-Cyl, 2.5 Liter
11.4 cu ft
166 lb-ft
3265 lbs
2.5i Sedan 4D
$3,770
23 MPG
168 @ 5600 RPM
4-Cyl, 2.5 Liter
11.4 cu ft
166 lb-ft
3200 lbs
See Full Specs for All 2005 Subaru Legacy Styles
Advertisement

2005 Subaru Legacy Depreciation

A 2005 Subaru Legacy has depreciated $519 or 15% in the last 3 years and has a current resale value of $2,791 and trade-in value of $943.

Login or create a new account to see your vehicle depreciation forecast data.

Historical
historical solid line
Forecast
forecast dash line
2005 Subaru Legacy
Compare up to 3 vehicles by logging in.

2005 Subaru Legacy Annual Depreciation

Year
Vehicle Depreciation*
Resale Value
Trade-In Value
2022
$35
$3,310
$1,711
2023
$255
$3,055
$1,243
2024
$186
$2,869
$1,048
Now
$78
$2,791
$943
Lock Icon

Unlock Forecast

2-Year Forecasted Depreciation

*Depreciation for the last 12 months of the private party resale value.

2005 Subaru Legacy Depreciation

Annual Depreciation is an estimation of what your vehicle's value might be over time based on an average of similar vehicles. Estimations are calculated by comparing Kelley Blue Book Private Party Values of vehicles similar to yours over time, as well as forecasts from Manheim Auction data comparing current and projected auction values against current Kelley Blue Book Private Party and Trade-In Values. This is not a guarantee of actual depreciation. Local weather conditions, market factors and driver performance will also impact your vehicle's actual depreciation.


Is this information helpful?
Learn More About 2005 Subaru Legacy Depreciation

Already Own This Car?

See Cars for Sale

Specifications

Dimensions, Weights & Capacities

Curb Weight
3300 lbs.
EPA Total Interior
93.1 cu.ft.
Fuel Capacity
16.9 gallons
Front Head Room
39.5 inches
Front Leg Room
44.1 inches
Max Seating Capacity
5
Minimum Ground Clearance
5.9 inches
Overall Length
186.2 inches
Front Shoulder Room
54.4 inches
Towing Capacity, Maximum
2700 lbs.
Trunk or Cargo Capacity
11.4 cu.ft.
Turning Diameter
35.4 feet
Wheel Base
105.1 inches
Width with mirrors
68.1 inches

Exterior

Alloy Wheels
Available
Moon Roof/Sun Roof
Available
Number of Doors
4 doors
Rear Spoiler
Available

Fuel Economy

City
17 mpg
Highway
23 mpg
Combined
19 mpg

Mechanical

Drivetrain
AWD
Transmission Type
Automatic
Recommended Fuel
Premium

Performance

Horsepower
250 @ 6000 RPM
Torque
250 @ 3600 rpm
Engine
4-Cyl, Turbo, 2.5 Liter

Warranty

Basic
3 years / 36000 miles
Powertrain
5 years / 60000 miles
Corrosion
5 years / Unlimited miles

Entertainment

  • DVD Entertainment System
  • MP3 Player
  • CD Player

Interior

  • Power Windows
  • Tilt Steering Wheel

Seating

  • Leather Seats
  • Dual Power Front Seats
  • Power Driver's Seat

Technology

  • Cruise Control
  • Hands Free Phone
  • Navigation System

2005 Subaru Legacy Safety

2005 Subaru Legacy Safety Technology

  • Child Door Locks
  • Child Seat Anchors
  • Driver Airbag
  • Passenger Airbag
  • Rear Side Airbag
  • Front Side Airbag

Compare to Similar Vehicles

Used 2005
Subaru Legacy
Used 2006
Kia Optima (2006.5)
Used 2005
Pontiac Grand Am
Used 2005
Saturn L-Series
See Details
Price
$3,447
$3,277
$2,697
$2,960
Consumer Rating
4.5
4.6
3.9
4.4
Fuel Economy
City 17/Hwy 23/Comb 19 MPG
City 21/Hwy 31/Comb 25 MPG
City 18/Hwy 27/Comb 21 MPG
City 18/Hwy 26/Comb 21 MPG
Fuel Type
Gas
Gas
Gas
Gas
Seating Capacity5555
Basic Warranty
3 years or 36000 miles
5 years or 60000 miles
3 years or 36000 miles
3 years or 36000 miles
Horsepower
250 @ 6000 RPM
161 @ 5800 RPM
170 @ 5200 RPM
182 @ 5600 RPM
Engine
4-Cyl, Turbo, 2.5 Liter
4-Cyl, 2.4 Liter
V6, 3.4 Liter
V6, 3.0 Liter
Drivetrain
AWD
FWD
FWD
FWD

2005 Subaru Legacy Rankings

More Subaru Legacy News & Information

General
How Subaru Keeps Winning 2 of Our Most Important Awards

Subaru achieved something unusual this year. The Japanese brand won two of our Brand Image Awards. We think it’s worth…

Sean Tucker October 01, 2022
Midsize Car
2023 Subaru Legacy: New Safety Tech, Revised Styling

The Subaru Legacy has always been a solid but quirky choice among midsize family cars. It’s also the oddball on…

Sean Tucker May 13, 2022
Midsize Car
Which 2022 Subaru Legacy is Right for Me?

Subaru is known for safety and reliability, and the 2022 Subaru Legacy touts both qualities. The Subaru Legacy is a…

Abigail Bassett January 13, 2022

FAQs

Is 2005 a good year for a Subaru Legacy?

Owners of the vehicle give it 4.5 out of 5 stars. To find out if the 2005 Legacy is the right car for you, check out the pros and cons, trims, specs and options at Kelley Blue Book.

Is the Subaru Legacy 2005 a good vehicle?

Owners of the vehicle give it 4.5 out of 5 stars. To find out if the 2005 Legacy is the right car for you, check out the pros and cons, trims, specs and options at Kelley Blue Book.

What is the MPG for a 2005 Subaru Legacy?

The 2005 Subaru Legacy gets 17 mpg in the city and 23 mpg on the highway.

Also from Subaru

  • 2005 Subaru Baja
  • 2005 Subaru Forester
  • 2005 Subaru Impreza
  • 2005 Subaru Outback
Advertisement