Kelley Blue Book


HomeGMCGMC Sierra 25002017 GMC Sierra 2500 HD Crew Cab
Consumer Reviews

2017 GMC Sierra 2500 HD Crew Cab Consumer Reviews

Save this car
Write a Review
4.6
(32 reviews)
2017 GMC Sierra 2500 HD Crew Cab
5
78%
4
16%
3
0%
2
3%
1
3%
90%
Recommend this vehicle
Value
4.6
Performance
4.7
Quality
4.7
Comfort
4.7
Reliability
4.8
Styling
4.7
2017 Sierra 2500 HD Crew Cab Overview
Among the 32 owners who provided feedback on the 2017 GMC Sierra 2500 HD Crew Cab for Kelley Blue Book, consumer sentiment is overwhelmingly positive, with 90% recommending the vehicle. As a whole, consumers found the vehicle's reliability and comfort to be its strongest features and value to be its weakest. 25 out of 32 of owners (78% of them) rank the 2017 Sierra 2500 HD Crew Cab five out of five stars. Overall, consumers seem aligned in their opinions of the 2017 GMC Sierra 2500 HD Crew Cab. Is it the right vehicle for for you? Check out Kelley Blue Book's consumer reviews and see for yourself.
See Cars for SaleBuild & Price

Most Helpful Reviews

Positive Review

"Wow! That's the truck you WANT to have handy."

Everyone was checking out Ford pickups. I took a hard look & test-drove out of curiousity. Meh. Initially, i was intent on a Chevy Silverado LTZ & caught a glimpse of the 2015 GMC 2500HD Sierra SLT Z71 (Vortec 6.0L V8 4x4). Cowgirl's Cadillac, you say..why not?! This is an elegant yet practical vehicle. True, it does use up a hefty bit of fuel, but anyone who has had a 2500 HD truck knows they are powerful fuel thirsty machines. After a year of OEM comparisons (Year/Make/Model), I made my way to several Certified GM lots here & there. I drove several various model GM pickups. Then, after months of looking for the best value..there it was! My "cowgirl Cadillac". Rides like a dream..what a TRUCK!! No small wonder they make a TX Edition. Texans "put a lot a store" by what makes for a worthy truck. Since I've lived where tornadoes & hurricanes can do their worst (raised to BE PREPARED) I need a truck that can tow/haul me, my canine krewe (plus a bevy of sundry household goods) reliably on very short notice or during mandatory hurricane evac. If you've been thru this - you won't squirm excessively over the extra cost of MPG's. Getting back home after a tornado/hurricane means waiting for the "dust to settle" & clearance to return home (most bad case scenarios - 4x4 is a must). I've primarily owned Chevy, Dodge, Pontiac, a couple foreign V4, and Jeep. No Fords (no offense). Depenability plus functionality, makes for practical. I'll take that 2015 GMC Sierra Crew 2500 6.0L V8 4x4 Z71, thank you. I know its all that I will need (and more overall value for the $). Anyone ever sit put inching along thru gridlock during hurricane evac w/a full load on? Another GMC..SOLD! I'll put in my next review at @ 500 miles - to post what, if any, "Cons" I come across. I keep all my vehicles, "till the wheels fall off". Best to all, Christmas 2014, many prayers go out to Mississippi tornado victims, from an old gal that remembers the aftermaths of "bad wind" what came thru TX, MS, LA, AL and GA.


VS

Critical Review

"2015 GMC 2500HD Diesel"

Vibration coming from tires at highway speeds. Been to dealer 4 times dealer blames the strengthened frame. Replaced tires still there. Whistling noise when temp. is higher than 90 degrees coming from firewall due to the lack of seam sealer. 38k Engine was replaced due to water getting in the oil. Dealer had for 3 months. Returned back for the same issue.

2017 Sierra 2500 HD Crew Cab Reviews

In our commitment to delivering the most comprehensive assessment of the vehicle possible, KBB.com widens the scope of our reviews to include all pertinent model years.
ex. Dependable

Showing 8 of 32 reviews.


George
3/7/2025
297

White. All highway miles making long distance parts deliveries. No accendents bed is dented up. No engine or transmission problems No towing done. All electric works. No off road use.

Was this review helpful?
0
0

Orlando
1/2/2025
Gret

Great and good service for all the information I got for knowing what the exact price for my car with out over paying

Value
4.0
Performance
4.0
Quality
4.0
Comfort
4.0
Reliability
4.0
Styling
4.0
Recommends this vehicle
Was this review helpful?
0
0

Jess
2/26/2023
Perfect condition!
Pros

4wd diesel

Like new condition! Seat covers 3 side steps each side Premium wheels A sharp, MUST SEE truck. Hard to find, too!

Value
5.0
Performance
5.0
Quality
5.0
Comfort
5.0
Reliability
5.0
Styling
5.0
Was this review helpful?
0
0

Alex P
2/21/2023
Great truck! Fantastic mpg
Pros

Comfortable great mpg reliable

Cons

CP4 injection pump expensive to buy initially

I have a 2016 Sierra SLT, it’s an extremely capable, reliable, and comfortable truck. Rides much better than my father-in-laws F250. Also in my experience the Duramax gets great mpg for such a big truck. I average 16 mpg mixed driving and have even gotten close to 25 mpg consistently going 60 mph. Currently have 39,000 trouble free miles on it and am planning on keeping it for many more years! I will say with the generation of these trucks that use the CP4 injection pump, make sure you always fuel up at high traffic stations and use a good additive in your fuel. The CP4 has zero tolerance for water contamination in the fuel. Still have 36,000 miles of my extended warranty and am planning on switching to a CP3 injection pump after the warranty expires. That’s about the only weak link on these trucks!

Value
4.0
Performance
5.0
Quality
5.0
Comfort
5.0
Reliability
5.0
Styling
4.0
Recommends this vehicle
Was this review helpful?
0
0

Alfa Meli
10/9/2022
Saudi
Pros

Ok

Cons

No

أحتاج إلى هذه السيارة، أريد 15000 كم how are you please quickly replacement gddhhdGmcgfs do khgfddfjfdddnn

Value
4.0
Performance
4.0
Quality
4.0
Comfort
4.0
Reliability
4.0
Styling
4.0
Recommends this vehicle
Was this review helpful?
0
0

Big Red
10/6/2022
Most reliable
Pros

The torque

Cons

Hard ride without load

My 2019 GMC Denali has astonishing torque and power, even while pulling my camper in and around Colorado, including over passes. Nothing short of awe-inspiring! Owner: TM

Value
5.0
Performance
5.0
Quality
5.0
Comfort
4.0
Reliability
5.0
Styling
5.0
Recommends this vehicle
Was this review helpful?
0
0

Bobby
1/21/2022
Like new

Absolutely no scratches. Been extremely well cared for. Used o pull 41 ft 5rh wheel camper. A real beautiful truck!

Value
5.0
Performance
5.0
Quality
5.0
Comfort
5.0
Reliability
5.0
Styling
5.0
Recommends this vehicle
Was this review helpful?
1
0

Douglas
12/15/2021
You are the best!

I was looking for a place to find a fair quote for my vehicle and on the recommendation of a friend I found you. All the evaluation software seems perfect to me. Thanks a lot.

Value
5.0
Performance
5.0
Quality
5.0
Comfort
5.0
Reliability
5.0
Styling
5.0
Recommends this vehicle
Was this review helpful?
1
0

More 2017 GMC Sierra 2500 Consumer Reviews

  • 2017 GMC Sierra 2500 HD Double Cab Consumer Reviews
  • 2017 GMC Sierra 2500 HD Regular Cab Consumer Reviews
kbb-logo-mini

Reviews You Can Trust

Kelley Blue Book has been a respected figure in the automotive world since 1926. Our commitment to maintaining this legacy is evident in our Consumer Reviews and Ratings. To ensure our customers receive candid, genuine, and impartial car reviews, we've teamed up with Bazaarvoice, a leader in the industry that employs cutting-edge fraud protection and state-of-the-art protocols to guarantee the authenticity of each review. At Kelley Blue Book, trust is the cornerstone of our relationship with our valued customers, and it’s the guiding principle in everything we do.
Advertisement