By Joe Tralongo
Updated December 23, 2019
If you’re a driving purist, Ferrari’s mid-engine 458 Italia for 2012 is the Holy Grail of high-end performance cars. Its look is more exotic than the Audi R8 and its interior more organic than that of either the R8 or Lamborghini Gallardo.
The R8 may not have the Italia’s seductive Italian good looks, but it certainly can match the Ferrari in power, handling and performance and does so for about $100K less.
A convertible Spider joins the 458 Italia coupe for 2012. The Spider’s retractable aluminum hardtop fits neatly below the clamshell engine cover and can be retracted in about about 14 seconds.
Ferrari really nailed it with the 2012 458 Italia and its new drop-top stablemate, the 458 Spider. The mid-engine design allows for a near-perfect 50/50 front-rear balance ratio and the car’s 4.5-liter V8 is simply a masterpiece in aluminum and steel. That the 458 can rocket to 60 mph in less the 4 seconds isn’t really surprising, but that it can manage that power so precisely in the turns is what truly makes this exotic stand out. We do lament the lack of a manual transmission, but Ferrari’s 7-speed automatic with paddle-shifting manual mode won’t disappoint. The fun only increases with the Spider that not only lets you enjoy the wind in your hair, but the sound of the V8 engine directly behind your head.
The Kelley Blue Book Fair Purchase Price for any individual used vehicle can vary greatly according to mileage, condition, location, and other factors, but here's a general idea of what buyers are currently paying for used 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia models when purchasing from a dealership.
There isn’t a single bad thing we can say about the way the 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia drives. It’s like a go-kart on steroids, doing everything the driver asks without the annoyance of numerous electronic nannies stepping in to spoil the fun. The perfectly balanced chassis is so composed at high speeds it can create in the driver a false sense of F1 -like confidence he or she won’t be able to replicate in any other car. From the brilliant dual-clutch transmission whose shifts occur in just nanoseconds to the precise steering that so utterly connects driver to car, the 458 is quite possibly the best Ferrari – and maybe even the best car – built today. Because we don’t want to sound one-sided, here is our short list of complaints: The steering wheel has too many controls (wipers, turn signals, starter) attached to it, legroom is somewhat lacking and none of us can afford one.
Because the 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia and 458 Spider are mid-engine cars, the bulkhead separating the driver from the engine compartment can restrict the ability to recline the front seats when they are at their rearmost travel. Legroom, on the other hand, is surprisingly good. The 458’s gorgeous cockpit is covered in fine leathers and eye-pleasing shapes, all of which can be enhanced via the numerous interior upgrade options. We think placing so many controls on the steering wheel is unwise, and the instrumentation could be a bit less complicated, with simple gauges replacing the dual-purpose LCD screens for both speed and navigation.
Enthusiasts may call the Ferrari’s 458 for 2012 a work of art, but it’s really all about efficiency. From the open vent louvers atop the fenders to the available integrated carbon fiber rear diffuser, the 458’s design is all about channeling air to improve handling and efficiency. On the Spider, Ferrari has created an aluminum retractable hardtop that actually weighs less than most soft-top mechanisms, adding a mere 100 pounds over the coupe.
7-SPEED DUAL CLUTCH AUTOMATIC
While a manual might feel more engaging, Ferrari’s 7-speed dual clutch automatic can beat the best driver every time. Ferrari says there is zero power loss to the rear wheels between gear changes and that means no performance loss whatsoever when the driver is doing the shifting.
4.5-LITER V8
It’s simply mind boggling to think Ferrari can milk a modest-sized V8 engine for 562 horsepower and do it without turbochargers or gimmicks, but that’s exactly what the 458 Italia and Spider provide.
Standard on the 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia and Spider is a full leather interior, electronic traction and stability control, seat-mounted side airbags, adjustable suspension settings, a power tilt/telescopic steering wheel, ceramic brakes with 6-piston calipers, 20-inch alloy wheels, dual-zone automatic climate control, bi-xenon automatic headlamps, Bluetooth and heated power side mirrors. The Spider includes a power retractable hardtop.
Among the 2012 458’s more notable options are numerous paint and interior color choices, upgraded leather, carbon fiber racing seats, a choice of three different seat styles with power-seat upgrade, cruise control, navigation, adaptive front headlights, front and rear parking sensors, various carbon fiber add-ons, 1000-watt JBL premium audio system, various 20-inch wheels and a rear backup camera.
The Ferrari 458 Italia and 458 Spider are both powered by the same hand-built aluminum 4.5-liter V8 engine. Pumping out an amazing 562 horsepower, the 458’s engine barely seems to strain to move the car to its nearly 200-mph top speed. And with an insane 9,000-rpm redline, why should it? The 7-speed dual-clutch automatic does just fine by itself. But, if the driver wants in on the action, a set of steering-wheel paddle shifters allows for instantaneous up/down shifts perfectly rev-matched.
4.5-liter V8
562 horsepower @ 9,000 rpm
398 lb-ft of torque @ 6,000 rpm
EPA city/highway fuel economy: 12/18 mpg
Max Seating Capacity | 2 | ||
---|---|---|---|
Overall Length | 178.2 inches | ||
Wheel Base | 104.3 inches | ||
Width with mirrors | 76.3 inches |
Adaptive Headlights | Available | ||
---|---|---|---|
Alloy Wheels | Available | ||
Number of Doors | 2 doors |
City | 12 mpg | ||
---|---|---|---|
Highway | 17 mpg | ||
Combined | 14 mpg |
Drivetrain | RWD | ||
---|---|---|---|
Transmission Type | Automatic | ||
7 speed | Available | ||
Recommended Fuel | Premium |
Horsepower | 570 @ 9000 RPM | ||
---|---|---|---|
Torque | 398 @ 6000 rpm | ||
Engine | V8, 4.5 Liter |
Basic | 3 years / Unlimited miles | ||
---|---|---|---|
Powertrain | 3 years / Unlimited miles | ||
Corrosion | 3 years / Unlimited miles |
Used 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia | Used 2019 McLaren 570GT | Used 2017 Dodge Viper | New 2025 Mercedes-Benz Mercedes-AMG GT | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Price | $150,921 | $138,977 | $136,987 | $138,700 | |
Consumer Rating | 5.0 | 4.0 | 3.1 | N/A | |
Fuel Economy | City 12/Hwy 17/Comb 14 MPG | City 15/Hwy 22/Comb 18 MPG | City 12/Hwy 19/Comb 14 MPG | City 12/Hwy 19/Comb 14 MPG | |
Fuel Type | Gas | Gas | Gas | Gas | |
Seating Capacity | 2 | 2 | 2 | 4 | |
Basic Warranty | 3 years | 3 years | 3 years or 36000 miles | 4 years or 50000 miles | |
Horsepower | 570 @ 9000 RPM | 562 @ 7500 RPM | 645 @ 6200 RPM | 469 @ 5500 RPM | |
Engine | V8, 4.5 Liter | V8, Twin Turbo, 3.8 Liter | V10, 8.4 Liter | V8, Twin Turbo, 4.0 Liter | |
Drivetrain | RWD | RWD | RWD | AWD |
Making good on its promise to create a limited run of cars based on a striking concept revealed at the…
Ferrari 458 Spider It’s a deep red thing. Red is the color of passion. The color of fire and lust.…
Yes, the 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia is a good car. Its Kelley Blue Book rating of 0 out of 5 is within 10% of our average rating.
The 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia is rated to return city/highway fuel economy of 12/17 mpg.
The 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia is part of the 1st-generation 458 Italia, which our owners give an above-average reliability rating of 4.2 out of 5.