Honda Civic
What’s for sale near me?
Above Average: Excellent reputation for dependability and safety; strong resale; excellent fuel economy; roomy rear seat; wide range of models, body styles and powertrains
Below Average: Somewhat generic styling until 2016 model; hatchback didn’t arrive until 2017
Consensus: A terrific car for those who value value and want something fun, smart and comfortable
Toyota Corolla
What’s for sale near me?
Above Average: Low price; good fuel economy; spacious interior and trunk; nice interior; excellent reputation for reliability, longevity and high resale
Below Average: Limited engine choices (and not very powerful); CVT-equipped models rev a bit too high and loud; limited number of cutting-edge features; sedan only
Consensus: A reliable, affordable compact sedan for those who need basic transportation without a lot of complicated bells and whistles
Both Honda and Toyota share a reputation for value, high resale and owner loyalty. Honda brings a bit more flair to the table, with cars that cater to varying segments ranging from boy racers to penny pinchers. Toyota focuses on basic needs, building a compact car that does everything well, but nothing spectacularly. Both brands have seen a few slips over the last 10 years, but they’ve recovered their reputations as well as the trust of their loyal customer base. Newer models offer cutting edge safety features like adaptive cruise control and automatic emergency braking, with Honda offering them first in 2016, but Toyota bringing them on after 2017.
Honda Civic Advantages
The Civic was completely redone in 2016 and has a more dynamic look, as well as more powerful engines including a hybrid model. Prior to 2016, the Civic still offered more personality than the Corolla, with sedan and coupe models, the sporty Si, and even a natural-gas-powered model.
Toyota Corolla Advantage
The current Corolla debuted in 2013, but its styling is still rather generic, and it uses the same 1.8-liter engine and mechanicals as the previous generation. Interior materials are better than in the past, and there is plenty of room for passengers and cargo. The Corolla sits up a bit higher than the Civic, with more glass for better visibility, and more headroom for taller drivers. Excellent fuel economy, strong safety ratings, and class-leading resale continue to be the Corolla’s strongest selling points.
Similarities
Both the Corolla and Civic appeal to those who need basic transportation that is dependable, affordable and respectable. Neither car is terribly flashy or cutting edge, but they both have the necessary bits to appeal to their intended buyer. There’s nothing overly complicated about the controls, audio systems or mechanicals, another bonus for those who like things simple and uncomplicated.
Final Recommendation
While the Corolla is a fine car in every respect, it’s a bit one-dimensional. The Civic offers everything the Corolla has, but does so with a bit more style, offering a choice of sedan or coupe plus various engine and transmissions choices.
OK, so what’s next?
I’m ready for one of these cars, and I’d like to trade in my current car while I’m at it.
